Good morning. Today: a case that will send you back to your operation notes, a four-year trial that tells you where not to spend hospital money, and one number worth giving the husband sitting in your fertility clinic.
— DR. ADITYA SETH, EDITOR-IN-CHIEF
01 · THE LEAD
MEDI
COLEGAL
A D&C with no record behind it has just cost an obstetrician ₹3 lakh
A woman delivered a baby girl by caesarean and went home two days later. The pain and the bleeding did not settle. She says that each time she came back, she was told this was normal and would pass with medicines. Three weeks on, days before moving cities for her husband’s job, she came in again and left with the same advice. Nobody ordered a scan.
Two months of medicines later, a gynaecologist in the new city scanned her and found pregnancy tissue still sitting in the uterus. A second gynaecologist nearer home measured it at 7 × 4.2 × 4.1 cm. Her original obstetrician did a D&C and sent the tissue for biopsy. A repeat scan two weeks after that showed the tissue was still there. Three months later another hospital cleared the uterus by suction, and she told the court her symptoms improved by about 60%. The district consumer commission at Yamuna Nagar has ordered the doctor and the hospital to pay ₹3 lakh with 7% interest from the day she filed, plus ₹11,000 in costs, rising to 9% if it is not paid inside 45 days.
Almost all of the reasoning rests on documents the hospital held and never produced.
WHY IT MATTERS
Five drugs on the prescription from a visit the hospital called routine, which the commission read as treatment for real pain and bleeding, leaving the missing ultrasound hard to defend.
The hospital never filed its own record of the D&C, and its slip named neither the procedure nor the biopsy, so the one report it was relying on reached the court from the patient.
Records a hospital holds and does not produce, the commission held, count against the hospital.
02 · RESEARCH
68 theatres, 110,538 operations and four years later, the air purifiers had changed nothing
Cleveland Clinic put two hospital-grade purifiers in each of 68 operating theatres, then swapped half of them every four weeks for identical machines that had been gutted at the factory. The fans still ran, the lights still glowed, and standing in the room there was no way to tell which month you were in. Out of every 1,000 inpatients, 81 had an infection, a wound complication or died within 30 days with the real units running. With the dummies, 82. The safety board stopped the trial early. Whether any of that applies to your theatre turns entirely on what those machines were being added to.
1,235 couples, every wife a non-smoker, and the pack-a-day husbands took home 42 babies per 100 against 59
Fertility clinics have counselled women about cigarettes for thirty years and given the man beside her a sentence. The evidence on him stayed contradictory since the 1990s, largely because the comparison groups kept including women who smoked too. This study excluded any woman who had smoked in the three months before treatment, then measured cotinine, the chemical the body makes out of nicotine, in the men’s blood on the morning of egg collection, so nobody could quietly under-report. Self-declared non-smokers came in under 1 ng/ml. The pack-a-day men came in at 222. After adjustment their couples had a 19% lower chance of a live birth, and miscarriage rates were identical across all three groups, so the pregnancies were going somewhere else.
03 · AIR QUALITY
|
What did you think of today's email?
Built by doctors. Read by doctors.
Know a colleague who should be reading this? Forward this email to them.
Forwarded this issue? Subscribe free →